Cosmology: an expanding universeCosmology: an expanding universe
Follow expanding distances, derive their evolution, and calculate the light we receive.Follow expanding distances, derive their evolution, and calculate the light we receive.
1 calculation laboratory
1 worked example in this chapter
Before you begin
What controls the expansion and acceleration of the universe?
- Measure energy and momentum flux ↗Compare the energy density of dust in its rest frame and a boosted frame.
- Trace reverse and identify the Newtonian source ↗Recover the factor of one half in the trace-reversed source.
- A law needs a starting state ↗Use seconds and metres. For , , , find .
By the end: Derive Friedmann evolution and distinguish redshift, distance, and horizons.
Follow three widely separated galaxies carried by an expanding background. If every separation grows by the same fraction during the same time, one function can describe that common change: the scale factor. We first study this smooth background, then use it to calculate the light received from a distant source. Individual galaxies and other departures from uniformity require additional structure.Follow three widely separated galaxies carried by an expanding background. If every separation grows by the same fraction during the same time, one function can describe that common change: the scale factor. We first study this smooth background, then use it to calculate the light received from a distant source. Individual galaxies and other departures from uniformity require additional structure.
Homogeneity says no spatial location is special in the background model. Isotropy says no spatial direction is special for its fundamental observers. Neither assumption requires time independence. The universe is allowed to evolve while treating every background location equivalently.Homogeneity says no spatial location is special in the background model. Isotropy says no spatial direction is special for its fundamental observers. Neither assumption requires time independence. The universe is allowed to evolve while treating every background location equivalently.
19.1 A metric for uniform expansion#19.1 A metric for uniform expansion
Attach spatial labels to the background observers so their labels stay fixed during expansion. Such coordinates are called comoving. Use the chart , with in seconds and the spatial labels dimensionless. The common scaling and spatial symmetries lead to
where has units of length and is dimensionless. This is the Friedmann–Lemaître–Robertson–Walker (FLRW) metric. For , the displayed radial chart has and does not cover the whole closed spatial geometry; Section 19.7 gives a radial coordinate that continues past this patch. The angular coordinates have their usual pole limitations.
At fixed time, isotropy makes the sectional curvature the same for every spatial two-plane, and homogeneity makes it the same at each point. Call that value . In an orthonormal spatial frame the curvature therefore has the form . Contracting gives , and a second contraction gives
Positive describes positive constant spatial curvature, negative negative curvature, and zero flat spatial slices. Local curvature does not by itself settle every global topology question.
Some books instead make dimensionless and place length units in the spatial coordinates or curvature parameter. Either convention works. Combining the formulas without converting conventions does not. Here, when we want a dimensionless normalized scale factor, we will explicitly write .
Observers at fixed comoving coordinates have . The cosmic time is their proper time; it is not a new absolute Newtonian time available in every spacetime. It is singled out by this geometry and matter congruence.
The Hubble parameter isThe Hubble parameter is
with units of inverse time. It measures the fractional expansion rate. An expansion factor is a ratio of scale factors, while is a rate of change. For example, doubling all distances is an expansion factor of two; taking a billion years to do so and taking two billion years imply different expansion rates.
More distance. The same cosmic grid.
Choose a scale factor. Every comoving separation grows together; no point in the grid becomes a preferred center of the expansion.
Read the scene. The highlighted segment measures the changing separation of two fixed comoving markers. This is a finite window into a spatially flat FLRW slice, not a universe with an outer edge. The control selects a scale factor; it does not specify a cosmological expansion history.Read the scene. The highlighted segment measures the changing separation of two fixed comoving markers. This is a finite window into a spatially flat FLRW slice, not a universe with an outer edge. The control selects a scale factor; it does not specify a cosmological expansion history.
19.2 Calculating the spacetime curvature#19.2 Calculating the spacetime curvature
Write the spatial bracket as , so and has unit constant curvature . The useful connection coefficients are
The first says spatial motion participates in time evolution because spatial distances depend on time. The second says a spatial basis carried through cosmic time changes its scale. The third contains the ordinary intrinsic connection of the constant-curvature spatial geometry.The first says spatial motion participates in time evolution because spatial distances depend on time. The second says a spatial basis carried through cosmic time changes its scale. The third contains the ordinary intrinsic connection of the constant-curvature spatial geometry.
For the time-time Ricci component, . The relevant contraction gives
The cancellation uses . There are three equal spatial contributions because there are three equivalent spatial directions.
For the spatial Ricci components, the intrinsic curvature contributes . The time-dependent pieces are , the trace product , and the two remaining mixed products totaling . Adding them gives
Contract with and :
Notice that does not generally make this vanish. Spatial flatness is not spacetime flatness. Evolving distances generate spacetime curvature even when every spatial slice is intrinsically Euclidean.
Combining Ricci and its trace givesCombining Ricci and its trace gives
andand
The component has inverse-time-squared units because this chart uses , not . The mixed spatial components have inverse-length-squared units. The coordinate units explain the difference, just as the metric’s component carries when is measured in seconds.
19.3 The Friedmann equations: what controls expansion and acceleration#19.3 The Friedmann equations: what controls expansion and acceleration
Homogeneity and isotropy select a perfect-fluid background stress-energy tensor. Let be physical rest-frame energy density and pressure. In the comoving chart,
Substitute the time-time components into :
Divide by three and rearrange:Divide by three and rearrange:
This is the first Friedmann equation. In mass-equivalent density , the matter term is . That conversion explains many apparently different textbook versions.
The spatial equation givesThe spatial equation gives
Eliminate using the first equation:
This is the acceleration equation. Energy density and isotropic pressure both gravitate. The factor three counts the three equal spatial pressures in the rest frame.This is the acceleration equation. Energy density and isotropic pressure both gravitate. The factor three counts the three equal spatial pressures in the rest frame.
A positive expansion rate does not imply accelerating expansion . A ball thrown upward moves upward while slowing. Likewise, a matter-filled model can grow in size while its growth rate decreases.
Conversely, a positive cosmological constant contributes positively to . If it dominates, expansion accelerates. The equations make the condition quantitative instead of relying on the ambiguous phrase “repulsive gravity.”
19.4 Energy conservation during expansion#19.4 Energy conservation during expansion
Use the mixed components and . The time component of their covariant divergence is
Setting it to zero givesSetting it to zero gives
For a fixed comoving volume, its physical volume is proportional to . Multiply the conservation equation by :
This has the familiar form . As the volume expands, positive pressure reduces the energy within that comoving volume. The fluid does expansion work in this local continuum sense.
These equations are not three independent pieces of information. Differentiate the first Friedmann equation and use the continuity equation; away from a turning point, dividing by recovers the acceleration equation. At , use the original Einstein and conservation equations rather than dividing by zero. The undivided equations remain valid at a turning point.
For a separately conserved component with constant equation-of-state parameterFor a separately conserved component with constant equation-of-state parameter
the continuity equation becomesthe continuity equation becomes
Integrate:Integrate:
The integration is a statement about dilution and work, not an additional gravitational law. If components exchange energy, each gets an exchange term and need not obey this separate scaling; the total still obeys conservation.The integration is a statement about dilution and work, not an additional gravitational law. If components exchange energy, each gets an exchange term and need not obey this separate scaling; the total still obeys conservation.
| Component | Approximate | Energy-density scaling | Physical reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nonrelativistic matter, or dust | Approximately fixed rest energy per particle, diluted by volume | ||
| Radiation | Volume dilution plus redshift of each quantum’s energy | ||
| Cosmological constant as a fluid | Constant | Negative pressure exactly offsets dilution in the continuity equation |
The dust model does not mean microscopic dust grains specifically. It means negligible pressure relative to energy density at the scale and accuracy being modeled.The dust model does not mean microscopic dust grains specifically. It means negligible pressure relative to energy density at the scale and accuracy being modeled.
If is moved to the matter side, its effective density and pressure are
Either keep explicit in the Friedmann equations or include this component in total and remove the explicit term. Doing both counts the same effect twice.
A comoving volume filled with this effective component gains total energy as it grows, since its energy density remains constant. This does not violate the continuity equation; its negative pressure makes the right-hand side positive. In a general expanding spacetime there is no global timelike translation symmetry supplying a universally conserved total energy of the elementary mechanics kind.
19.5 Solving for the scale factor#19.5 Solving for the scale factor
Consider a spatially flat universe dominated by a single separately conserved constant- component, with no additional explicit . For , choose the expanding branch. Combining the first Friedmann equation with the density scaling gives
where is a constant with inverse-time units. Move the power of to the left and integrate:
The time is the integration constant locating in this classical idealized solution. The approximation is not a license to extrapolate an arbitrarily chosen matter model into the quantum-gravity regime.
For dust, ; for radiation, after shifting to zero. Both expand while decelerating. Radiation decelerates more strongly because its pressure also contributes to the acceleration equation.
For a positive cosmological constant alone in a spatially flat expanding slicing,For a positive cosmological constant alone in a spatially flat expanding slicing,
For , the density is constant, so the first Friedmann equation makes constant. Integrating gives the exponential directly. This case was excluded when we divided by in the power-law integration.
More generally, a positive-density single component with produces acceleration in the flat model. That criterion depends on the total effective when multiple components are present.
A realistic background calculation combines components with different scalings. Radiation fades fastest, matter more slowly, and a cosmological-constant density stays fixed. Different terms can therefore dominate at different epochs without any of them abruptly changing its fundamental identity.A realistic background calculation combines components with different scalings. Radiation fades fastest, matter more slowly, and a cosmological-constant density stays fixed. Different terms can therefore dominate at different epochs without any of them abruptly changing its fundamental identity.
19.6 Cosmological redshift, derived from neighboring wave crests#19.6 Cosmological redshift, derived from neighboring wave crests
Define a radial comoving distance coordinate along a ray byDefine a radial comoving distance coordinate along a ray by
Radial null propagation gives . For a fixed comoving source and receiver, the comoving distance traversed by a light signal is
A neighboring wave crest leaves at and arrives at . It crosses the same comoving separation. Subtract the two integrals, treating the periods as short compared with the expansion time:
The comoving clocks measure these coordinate intervals as proper periods. Frequency is inverse period, soThe comoving clocks measure these coordinate intervals as proper periods. Frequency is inverse period, so
A photon observed at redshift was emitted when the scale factor was one third its value at observation. Its observed wavelength is three times its emitted wavelength, assuming no additional peculiar-motion or local gravitational shifts.
Photon energy is proportional to frequency, so it scales as . Combined with number-density dilution , this independently explains radiation’s energy-density law. The light-propagation and fluid-conservation calculations give the same density scaling.
This redshift differs from comparing stationary observers in a static potential. Generic FLRW spacetime has no corresponding global timelike Killing symmetry. A useful alternative interpretation builds the redshift from many small local Doppler shifts between neighboring comoving observers. What one should not do is pretend all widely separated cosmological observers share one global special-relativistic inertial frame.This redshift differs from comparing stationary observers in a static potential. Generic FLRW spacetime has no corresponding global timelike Killing symmetry. A useful alternative interpretation builds the redshift from many small local Doppler shifts between neighboring comoving observers. What one should not do is pretend all widely separated cosmological observers share one global special-relativistic inertial frame.
19.7 Conformal time and radial light rays#19.7 Conformal time and radial light rays
Define dimensionless conformal time byDefine dimensionless conformal time by
ThenThen
The radial functions follow by integrating near the origin: for , for , and for . Thus , , and .
In the closed case, continues smoothly through , where ceased to be a usable radial coordinate. The endpoints are the two poles of this spherical spatial chart. Radial light rays now satisfy .
A plot of against now draws radial light at slopes and . Multiplying a metric by a positive conformal factor preserves its null cones. It does not preserve proper times, physical lengths, or affine parameters of null geodesics. The prefactor still determines the physical lengths and times represented by that plot.
This distinction becomes especially useful for horizons: what matters is how much conformal time has elapsed or remains, not merely whether today’s expansion rate sounds large.This distinction becomes especially useful for horizons: what matters is how much conformal time has elapsed or remains, not merely whether today’s expansion rate sounds large.
19.8 The Hubble radius and the two cosmological horizons#19.8 The Hubble radius and the two cosmological horizons
At fixed cosmic time, radial proper distance from the origin along a spatial slice is . A comoving object has fixed , so
This rate can exceed at sufficiently large . It is a rate of change of a nonlocal separation defined using cosmic simultaneity, not the velocity measured when one object passes another in the same local inertial frame. Special relativity’s local causal limit remains intact.
For a radial light ray,For a radial light ray,
An inward-directed ray can initially have increasing proper distance when . Whether it later approaches us depends on the subsequent expansion history. This makes the Hubble radius a useful instantaneous scale but not generally an event horizon.
| Distance at cosmic time | Formula | Question it answers |
|---|---|---|
| Hubble radius | Where does recession rate equal on this cosmic-time slice? | |
| Particle-horizon distance | How far could light have traveled to us since the model’s initial boundary? | |
| Event-horizon distance | Which comoving sources can ever communicate with us in the modeled future? |
The relevant horizon exists with finite distance only when the corresponding integral converges, with global topology and the spacetime’s actual domain also taken into account. The event-horizon upper limit is the future endpoint, often infinity; its existence therefore depends on future evolution.The relevant horizon exists with finite distance only when the corresponding integral converges, with global topology and the spacetime’s actual domain also taken into account. The event-horizon upper limit is the future endpoint, often infinity; its existence therefore depends on future evolution.
For an ideal flat dust universe beginning at ,
The future event-horizon integral diverges if that evolution continues forever: there is no cosmological event horizon in this model. Two distinct present-day distances and one absent horizon have emerged from a single simple scale factor.The future event-horizon integral diverges if that evolution continues forever: there is no cosmological event horizon in this model. Two distinct present-day distances and one absent horizon have emerged from a single simple scale factor.
For exponentially expanding flat de Sitter slicing, the future event horizon is . Its equality with the Hubble radius is a property of that special evolution, not a universal identity.
19.9 Does expansion stretch your atoms? And what exactly is dark energy?#19.9 Does expansion stretch your atoms? And what exactly is dark energy?
FLRW describes a smoothed cosmological background. A bound atom, planetary system, or galaxy is a local solution with its own stresses and gravitational field. You cannot obtain its size evolution by multiplying every internal distance by the background scale factor while ignoring the forces that bind it.FLRW describes a smoothed cosmological background. A bound atom, planetary system, or galaxy is a local solution with its own stresses and gravitational field. You cannot obtain its size evolution by multiplying every internal distance by the background scale factor while ignoring the forces that bind it.
Cosmological effects can appear as tiny tidal terms in suitable local approximations. Whether they matter is determined by comparing them with binding dynamics. “Everything stretches” is not the field equation; neither is “cosmology can never affect a bound system.” Specify the system and compare scales.Cosmological effects can appear as tiny tidal terms in suitable local approximations. Whether they matter is determined by comparing them with binding dynamics. “Everything stretches” is not the field equation; neither is “cosmology can never affect a bound system.” Specify the system and compare scales.
Dark matter and dark energy also play different dynamical roles. In the usual cosmological modeling, cold dark matter behaves approximately as pressureless matter, contributes to gravitational clustering, and has background density scaling approximately as . Dark energy labels the component or effective physics invoked for accelerated expansion; a cosmological constant is the simplest constant- realization. The equations alone do not identify dark matter’s particle properties or prove that dark energy is exactly a cosmological constant.
Type Ia supernovae are stellar explosions whose brightness can be calibrated using their observed light curves and spectra. Comparing that calibrated luminosity with the received flux defines a luminosity distance, worked out in Section 19.11. Historically, the relation between these distances and redshifts supplied evidence for accelerated expansion. A primary account is Riess and collaborators, Observational Evidence from Supernovae for an Accelerating Universe and a Cosmological Constant. Such an inference connects calibrated observations to a model for light propagation and cosmic evolution; it is not a direct photograph of negative pressure.Type Ia supernovae are stellar explosions whose brightness can be calibrated using their observed light curves and spectra. Comparing that calibrated luminosity with the received flux defines a luminosity distance , worked out in Section 19.11. Historically, the relation between these distances and redshifts supplied evidence for accelerated expansion. A primary account is Riess and collaborators, Observational Evidence from Supernovae for an Accelerating Universe and a Cosmological Constant. Such an inference connects calibrated observations to a model for light propagation and cosmic evolution; it is not a direct photograph of negative pressure.
The modern task is to confront expansion, lensing, clustering, and other observables together while checking systematics and assumptions. A successful fit within GR supports that description. It does not establish that every alternative gravitational theory is mathematically incapable of producing the same particular observations.The modern task is to confront expansion, lensing, clustering, and other observables together while checking systematics and assumptions. A successful fit within GR supports that description. It does not establish that every alternative gravitational theory is mathematically incapable of producing the same particular observations.
19.10 Comparing cosmological and black-hole curvature#19.10 Comparing cosmological and black-hole curvature
FLRW has zero Weyl curvature. To check this rather than infer it from spatial flatness, defineFLRW has zero Weyl curvature. To check this rather than infer it from spatial flatness, define
The orthonormal curvature components from the connection calculation are and , with the time-space mixed triples zero. They give , , and . Substituting these in Chapter 9’s Weyl decomposition gives, for example,
The spatial components cancel as . The mixed components are already zero. All curvature is therefore in the Ricci part; the metric is conformally flat, as defined in Chapter 9. The Schwarzschild vacuum exterior has the opposite pattern: its Ricci tensor vanishes while its Weyl tensor carries the tidal field.
There is a useful further check. A radiation-filled FLRW solution with has , so the traced Einstein equation gives . Yet is nonzero. The zero scalar is a cancellation in the contraction, not the absence of the individual Ricci components.
| Geometry or region | Ricci tensor | Weyl tensor | What this teaches |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minkowski spacetime | Zero | Zero | Full spacetime curvature vanishes |
| Schwarzschild vacuum exterior | Zero | Nonzero | Vacuum can contain tidal curvature |
| Nonempty radiation FLRW, | Nonzero, with scalar trace | Zero | Even zero scalar curvature need not mean zero Ricci curvature |
| de Sitter spacetime | Zero | A cosmological constant curves spacetime without Weyl tides |
The Einstein equation controls a particular contraction of curvature. Matter-filled cosmology, vacuum black holes, and vacuum gravitational waves demonstrate why that distinction matters. Geometry has both locally sourced structure and dynamical information carried through the spacetime solution.The Einstein equation controls a particular contraction of curvature. Matter-filled cosmology, vacuum black holes, and vacuum gravitational waves demonstrate why that distinction matters. Geometry has both locally sourced structure and dynamical information carried through the spacetime solution.
Vanishing Weyl curvature does not mean vanishing geodesic deviation. De Sitter spacetime, for example, has isotropic relative acceleration of neighboring comoving geodesics. The Ricci–Weyl split distinguishes parts of the tidal geometry; it does not assign all measurable gravitational effects to Weyl alone.Vanishing Weyl curvature does not mean vanishing geodesic deviation. De Sitter spacetime, for example, has isotropic relative acceleration of neighboring comoving geodesics. The Ricci–Weyl split distinguishes parts of the tidal geometry; it does not assign all measurable gravitational effects to Weyl alone.
19.11 Observe an expansion history#19.11 Observe an expansion history
Consider a comoving source seen at redshift , at radial coordinate from us. Let be the scale factor when we observe it. Its present radial distance along the cosmic-time slice is . A sphere at that coordinate has present area , which defines the transverse comoving distance . For flat spatial geometry these distances agree.
Suppose a small transverse feature had proper size when its light was emitted. The angular part of the metric gives for its small observed angle . The angular-diameter distance is the distance a Euclidean observer would infer from that size and angle:
Brightness supplies another measurement. Let the source radiate isotropically with luminosity , its emitted energy per unit proper time summed over all wavelengths. The received flux is energy per unit detector area per unit observer time, also summed over wavelengths. The photons spread over area . Each loses an energy factor , and their arrival intervals grow by . Thus
Define the luminosity distance by . Comparing the two expressions gives
At , the same source has . The definitions differ because the brightness measurement includes two redshift effects that the angle measurement does not. This calculation assumes the smooth FLRW model, light wavelengths short compared with the curvature scale, and no absorption or conversion of photons along the beam. The worked example now obtains these distances from an expansion history.
Compare those three distances below. Changing the Hubble constant changes the overall distance scale. Changing the matter and vacuum fractions changes how expansion proceeded and therefore changes the shapes of the curves. The vertical axis uses gigaparsecs; one gigaparsec is one thousand megaparsecs, the unit used in the readouts.Compare those three distances below. Changing the Hubble constant changes the overall distance scale. Changing the matter and vacuum fractions changes how expansion proceeded and therefore changes the shapes of the curves. The vertical axis uses gigaparsecs; one gigaparsec is one thousand megaparsecs, the unit used in the readouts.
Ask the universe three distance questions
Which distance did the observation actually measure?
- Comoving radialComoving radial
- Angular-diameterAngular-diameter
- LuminosityLuminosity
Change H₀ first, then the matter fraction. The dots mark your source redshift. Axes keep a common scale unless a curve needs more room.Change H₀ first, then the matter fraction. The dots mark your source redshift. Axes keep a common scale unless a curve needs more room.
How this is calculatedHow this is calculated
H₀ is in km s⁻¹ Mpc⁻¹. Readouts are Mpc and plotted distances are Gpc. Density parameters are relative to the present critical density.H₀ is in km s⁻¹ Mpc⁻¹. Readouts are Mpc and plotted distances are Gpc. Density parameters are relative to the present critical density.
- Homogeneous FLRW expansion with dust, spatial curvature and a cosmological constant; radiation is set to zero in this lab.Homogeneous FLRW expansion with dust, spatial curvature and a cosmological constant; radiation is set to zero in this lab.
- Geometric optics, isotropic bolometric source luminosity and photon-number conservation.Geometric optics, isotropic bolometric source luminosity and photon-number conservation.
- Composite Simpson integration; Ωₖ = 1 − Ωₘ − ΩΛ.Composite Simpson integration; Ωₖ = 1 − Ωₘ − ΩΛ.
This is an ideal background prediction. It does not fit an observational catalogue or include peculiar velocities, extinction, selection effects or lensing along a particular line of sight.This is an ideal background prediction. It does not fit an observational catalogue or include peculiar velocities, extinction, selection effects or lensing along a particular line of sight.
Hogg · Distance measures in cosmology ↗Measurements and notebookMeasurements and notebook
H₀ is in km s⁻¹ Mpc⁻¹. Readouts are Mpc and plotted distances are Gpc. Density parameters are relative to the present critical density.H₀ is in km s⁻¹ Mpc⁻¹. Readouts are Mpc and plotted distances are Gpc. Density parameters are relative to the present critical density.
| z | H | comoving | angular | luminosity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 70 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 0.5 | 91.604 | 1888.6 | 1259.1 | 2832.9 |
| 1 | 123.25 | 3303.8 | 1651.9 | 6607.7 |
| 1.5 | 162.48 | 4363.9 | 1745.5 | 10910 |
| 2 | 207.65 | 5179.9 | 1726.6 | 15540 |
| 2.5 | 257.79 | 5827.5 | 1665 | 20396 |
| 3 | 312.27 | 6355.7 | 1588.9 | 25423 |
| 3.5 | 370.65 | 6796.1 | 1510.3 | 30583 |
| 4 | 432.64 | 7170.4 | 1434.1 | 35852 |
| 4.5 | 498 | 7493.2 | 1362.4 | 41213 |
| 5 | 566.52 | 7775.4 | 1295.9 | 46652 |
Calculate three distances to one galaxyCalculate three distances to one galaxy
Why do brightness and angular size assign different distances to the same source?Why do brightness and angular size assign different distances to the same source?
See the idea
A cosmological distance is a prescription for inferring separation from measurements. Light travels while the scale factor changes. Its energy and arrival rate change, and a source’s transverse size belongs to its emission time. These facts make several useful distance definitions unequal.A cosmological distance is a prescription for inferring separation from measurements. Light travels while the scale factor changes. Its energy and arrival rate change, and a source’s transverse size belongs to its emission time. These facts make several useful distance definitions unequal.
Work it out
- Normalize the expansion history
The subscript 0 refers to the observation time, so . Keep this chapter’s length-valued a and define . Let be the present critical mass-equivalent density. Define , , , and . The Friedmann equation implies their sum is one. Separately conserved dust, radiation, and vacuum scale as , , and a constant.
Why this step works These scalings follow from the fluid equation with pressure-to-energy ratios 0, 1/3, and −1.
- Follow a radial null ray
Since , the present line-of-sight comoving distance is . The transverse comoving distance is , where , , and . This distinction is the geometry of spatial curvature.
Why this step works A radial distance and the radius inferred from a spherical area agree only in the flat case.
- Define angular and luminosity distances
For small observed angle θ and transverse proper source size at emission, define . For isotropic luminosity L and observed flux F, both summed over all wavelengths, define by . Redshift reduces each photon’s energy and stretches arrival times, giving two factors of in flux.
Why this step works The relation assumes metric null propagation, geometric optics, and photon-number conservation along the beam.
Go deeper
A low-z expansion gives ; at larger z, replacing the integral by is generally wrong. For a flat matter-only model , direct integration gives . The angular-diameter distance can turn over with redshift, so more distant objects need not always look smaller at fixed proper size. Absorption, source evolution, peculiar velocities, calibration uncertainties, and lensing must be handled before interpreting a real data set with this ideal homogeneous model.
Test the idea Test the idea
FIRST, PREDICTFIRST, PREDICT
At redshift z = 1, is luminosity distance equal to angular-diameter distance under the stated assumptions?At redshift z = 1, is luminosity distance equal to angular-diameter distance under the stated assumptions?
Compare the reasoningCompare the reasoning
Luminosity distance is half angular-diameter distance.Luminosity distance is half angular-diameter distance.
Both photon energy loss and slower arrival contribute to the luminosity relation.Both photon energy loss and slower arrival contribute to the luminosity relation.
No. Luminosity distance is four times angular-diameter distance.No. Luminosity distance is four times angular-diameter distance.
The distance-duality factor is (1+z)² = 4.The distance-duality factor is (1+z)² = 4.
Yes. A source has only one possible distance.Yes. A source has only one possible distance.
These distances encode different measurement protocols.These distances encode different measurement protocols.
A hintA hint
Apply distance duality before substituting z.Apply distance duality before substituting z.
NOW CHANGE THE EXAMPLENOW CHANGE THE EXAMPLE
In a flat matter-only model at z=3, find .
A hintA hint
Use the analytically integrated matter-only formula.Use the analytically integrated matter-only formula.
Work through the solutionWork through the solution
.
A distance formula is a measurement protocol with assumptions, not just a label on a diagram.A distance formula is a measurement protocol with assumptions, not just a label on a diagram.
19.12 A collapsing surface can cross its horizon in finite proper time#19.12 A collapsing surface can cross its horizon in finite proper time
A useful exact collapse model is a homogeneous pressureless ball, matched without a surface layer to a Schwarzschild exterior. It neglects pressure, rotation, inhomogeneity, and radiation. Use a closed FLRW interior,A useful exact collapse model is a homogeneous pressureless ball, matched without a surface layer to a Schwarzschild exterior. It neglects pressure, rotation, inhomogeneity, and radiation. Use a closed FLRW interior,
The surface follows a fixed . Starting at rest at maximum size, the dust Friedmann equation has the parametric solution
To check it, differentiate with respect to , use , and substitute into the closed dust Friedmann equation with conserved . The initial equation fixes , where is mass-equivalent energy density. The areal surface radius is , and the mass matching condition is
This spherical gravitational mass is not the integral of rest density over the curved proper volume. The matching conditions require continuity of the induced metric and extrinsic curvature in the absence of a surface stress tensor. Zero pressure at the dust boundary makes this interior/exterior matching possible.This spherical gravitational mass is not the integral of rest density over the curved proper volume. The matching conditions require continuity of the induced metric and extrinsic curvature in the absence of a surface stress tensor. Zero pressure at the dust boundary makes this interior/exterior matching possible.
The surface reaches when , hence at . Its proper time then is finite and smaller than the singular endpoint . For , crossing occurs at , while the surface has shrunk to one quarter of its initial radius.
The event horizon inside the dust is an outgoing radial null line, , traced backward from that crossing event. It obeys until it reaches the centre. For the specified example, it begins at the centre at , before the surface reaches its Schwarzschild radius. The horizon’s global definition and its smooth crossing by infalling matter are visible in the same solution. This exact dust model illustrates collapse; it is not a model of realistic stellar microphysics or an extension through its singular endpoint.
The idea to keepThe idea to keep
Expansion rate and acceleration are different questions. A universe can expand while slowing down.Expansion rate and acceleration are different questions. A universe can expand while slowing down.
Does positive pressure help accelerate expansion in the Friedmann acceleration equation?Does positive pressure help accelerate expansion in the Friedmann acceleration equation?
No, holding energy density and the cosmological constant fixed. Positive pressure adds to gravitational deceleration; sufficiently negative pressure can reverse the sign.No, holding energy density and the cosmological constant fixed. Positive pressure adds to gravitational deceleration; sufficiently negative pressure can reverse the sign.