Measurements and motionMeasurements and motion
Use a ruler and a clock to describe a moving cart. Then build the mechanics we need for gravity.Use a ruler and a clock to describe a moving cart. Then build the mechanics we need for gravity.
3 worked examples in this chapter
Before you begin
How can a few measurements help us predict motion?
- Differentiate, integrate, and use the chain rule ↗For f(x,y)=x²y along x=t, y=2t, find df/dt at t=1.
- Multiply matrices and read a bilinear form ↗For G=diag(1,4) and v=(3,2), calculate vᵀGv.
By the end: Read a partial derivative, interpret a differential equation, and explain force, energy, and flux.
Watch a small cart move along a straight track. Mark its position with a ruler and record the time with a clock. From those readings, can we work out how fast it is moving—and predict where it will be a moment later?Watch a small cart move along a straight track. Mark its position with a ruler and record the time with a clock. From those readings, can we work out how fast it is moving—and predict where it will be a moment later?
We will use this experiment to connect calculus with motion. Then we will add the ideas of force, energy, and flow that we need for gravity. If you have studied mechanics before, you can start with the five checks in §0.9.We will use this experiment to connect calculus with motion. Then we will add the ideas of force, energy, and flow that we need for gravity. If you have studied mechanics before, you can start with the five checks in §0.9.
0.1 A derivative is a local prediction#0.1 A derivative is a local prediction
Choose a mark on the track as the starting position and call it . The number tells us how far the cart is from that mark, with positive values to the right. Start the clock at . Suppose the measurements follow this pattern:
| Time in seconds | Position in metres |
|---|---|
| 0 | 0 |
| 1 | 3 |
| 2 | 12 |
| 3 | 27 |
During successive seconds the cart travels 3, then 9, then 15 metres. It is speeding up. One formula that fits these measurements isDuring successive seconds the cart travels 3, then 9, then 15 metres. It is speeding up. One formula that fits these measurements is
Four readings do not prove that this formula works at every time. We will use it as a model and see what it predicts.Four readings do not prove that this formula works at every time. We will use it as a model and see what it predicts.
The coefficient has units too: multiplying metres per second squared by seconds squared gives metres. A unit specifies what we count, such as metres or seconds. The dimension describes the kind of quantity, such as length or time. Metres and centimetres are different units of the same dimension.
The cart’s velocity is its rate of change of position, including direction. Its acceleration is the rate of change of velocity:The cart’s velocity is its rate of change of position, including direction. Its acceleration is the rate of change of velocity:
At , these give , and . The velocity predicts the next small change. Over , it predicts an extra . The exact change is . The extra comes from the increase in velocity during that tenth of a second.
Taylor’s formula keeps track of that correction:Taylor’s formula keeps track of that correction:
The symbol means a change; the dots stand for higher powers of that change. For this quadratic motion the displayed expression is exact. For a general smooth motion, keeping only the velocity term gives a local approximation. Shorten the time step, and the acceleration correction shrinks faster than the velocity contribution. A derivative predicts a small change, not a whole future at one fixed rate.
One distance, two ways to count itOne distance, two ways to count it
A table is 2 metres long, or 200 centimetres long. What changed when the number changed?A table is 2 metres long, or 200 centimetres long. What changed when the number changed?
See the idea
The table stayed the same. A centimetre is a smaller measuring step, so it takes more of them to span the table. A measurement needs both a number and a unit. Keeping those two parts together will help us read every physical equation in this book.The table stayed the same. A centimetre is a smaller measuring step, so it takes more of them to span the table. A measurement needs both a number and a unit. Keeping those two parts together will help us read every physical equation in this book.
Work it out
- Convert the unit and keep the length
One metre contains 100 centimetres. Multiply by a ratio equal to one, written with the new unit on top and the old unit below. The old unit cancels.
Why this step works Changing the unit changes the number used to describe a fixed length.
- Give a rate its two units
If a cart travels 2 metres in 4 seconds, its average speed is distance divided by elapsed time. Using centimetres gives a different number for the same average speed.
Why this step works Metres per second and centimetres per second describe the same kind of quantity: length divided by time.
- Count area in two directions
A square 2 metres on each side has area 4 square metres. Each side is also 200 centimetres, giving 40,000 square centimetres. Converting a squared length squares the conversion factor.
Why this step works An area contains one length factor from each direction, so both factors must be converted.
Go deeper
A dimension records the kind of quantity independently of the chosen unit. Write for the dimension of length and for time. Then , , and ; square brackets here mean “the dimensions of.” If , matching dimensions gives . Dimensional agreement is necessary but does not establish an equation: both and have consistent dimensions, but they predict different distances for the same and . Measurements or other physical reasoning must determine the numerical factor.
Test the idea Test the idea
FIRST, PREDICTFIRST, PREDICT
A cart’s speed is reported as 0.5 metres per second and 50 centimetres per second. Which statement is justified?A cart’s speed is reported as 0.5 metres per second and 50 centimetres per second. Which statement is justified?
Compare the reasoningCompare the reasoning
These can be two descriptions of the same speed.These can be two descriptions of the same speed.
There are 100 centimetres in one metre; both the number and the unit changed together.There are 100 centimetres in one metre; both the number and the unit changed together.
The second speed must be 100 times faster.The second speed must be 100 times faster.
Compare quantities in the same unit before comparing their numbers.Compare quantities in the same unit before comparing their numbers.
A speed needs only a number, because the units cancel.A speed needs only a number, because the units cancel.
Dividing a length by a time leaves length-per-time units.Dividing a length by a time leaves length-per-time units.
A hintA hint
Express both distances in centimetres while keeping the second unchanged.Express both distances in centimetres while keeping the second unchanged.
NOW CHANGE THE EXAMPLENOW CHANGE THE EXAMPLE
A rectangle is 2 metres long and 30 centimetres wide. What is its area in square metres?A rectangle is 2 metres long and 30 centimetres wide. What is its area in square metres?
A hintA hint
Convert the width to metres before multiplying.Convert the width to metres before multiplying.
Work through the solutionWork through the solution
, so the area is .
A physical measurement is a number with a unit. Convert both together before comparing quantities.A physical measurement is a number with a unit. Convert both together before comparing quantities.
0.2 Partial derivatives: change one input at a time#0.2 Partial derivatives: change one input at a time
Suppose a calculator takes two numbers and returns . Here , , and are dimensionless numbers. There are two different ways to change its output: change , or change .
The partial derivative holds fixed and differentiates with respect to . The other partial derivative is . We also write them as and . The symbol is a derivative with an instruction about what to hold fixed.
If a path through the inputs supplies and , both can change. The chain rule adds their contributions:
Try , , with dimensionless . Substitution gives , so . The chain rule gives too. Later we will use the same operation when a measurement depends on where and when we make it.
0.3 An integral adds local measurements#0.3 An integral adds local measurements
Water flows into an initially empty tank at a rate . The rate is measured in litres per second. If it is nearly constant during a short time , the added volume is approximately . Add the contributions from many short time steps. An integral is the limit as those steps become arbitrarily fine:
For with , the flow increases steadily. After three seconds,
The brackets mean evaluate at the upper limit and subtract the value at the lower limit. The contributes a time unit: flow rate multiplied by time gives volume. This is why checking units is part of understanding an integral.
The same addition works across a region of space. Mass density, written , is mass per volume. A small piece of volume contains approximately of mass. Adding all the pieces gives . For a uniform density in a rectangular box of volume , the integral is simply .
0.4 A differential equation needs starting measurements#0.4 A differential equation needs starting measurements
Near Earth’s surface, an ideal falling ball speeds up downward at nearly . Ignore air resistance and restrict attention to heights small compared with Earth’s radius. Choose upward as the positive direction. Its acceleration is then negative:
This is a differential equation: it specifies a derivative of the unknown function . Integrate once and then again:
The two constants have physical meanings: starting position and starting velocity . For a ball released from rest 20 metres above the ground, set and . After one second, the formulas give and . The negative velocity means downward motion. The model describes the fall until the ball hits the ground.
The acceleration law alone does not say whether the ball was dropped, thrown up, or thrown down. Those choices give different motions that obey the same law. A law plus starting measurements gives a prediction.The acceleration law alone does not say whether the ball was dropped, thrown up, or thrown down. Those choices give different motions that obey the same law. A law plus starting measurements gives a prediction.
A law needs a starting stateA law needs a starting state
What is missing when someone hands you an equation of motion?What is missing when someone hands you an equation of motion?
See the idea
A rule for change is not one particular history. Two identical swings obey the same equation but start at different positions and speeds. A solution must pass two tests: it must obey the differential equation everywhere in its domain, and it must match the stated initial measurements.A rule for change is not one particular history. Two identical swings obey the same equation but start at different positions and speeds. A solution must pass two tests: it must obey the differential equation everywhere in its domain, and it must match the stated initial measurements.
Work it out
- Solve proportional growth
For , the exponential works because differentiating it multiplies it by . Initial data fix . Positive means growth, negative decay. The product must be dimensionless.
Why this step works Differentiate the proposed solution and then check the starting value.
- Build an oscillator from two independent solutions
A dot means a time derivative: and . Let be a constant with units of inverse time. The oscillator equation says that acceleration points toward and grows with displacement. Both and return minus times themselves after two derivatives. The constants multiplying them are fixed by and .
Why this step works The position and velocity supply the two constants in a second-order equation.
- Rewrite second order as a system
Introduce a second variable . The pair , advances the state . A numerical method approximates this advance in small time steps; it must be checked against an exact solution and an error estimate.
Why this step works Adding a state variable changes the packaging, not the equation.
- Recognize rotating components
The transport system , has solution , . Differentiate and verify both equations. Also differentiate : the cross terms cancel.
Why this step works Components can change while the length of the represented arrow stays fixed.
Go deeper
Initial and boundary data answer different questions. For , prescribing and determines one solution. Prescribing leaves any , so this boundary-value problem is not unique. Existence and uniqueness of a first-order system are local under suitable smoothness conditions on its right-hand side; a solution can still become unbounded in finite time. For example, with dimensionless and gives , valid until . Always state the interval on which you use it.
Test the idea Test the idea
FIRST, PREDICTFIRST, PREDICT
A particle obeys . You know only . Is its history determined?
Compare the reasoningCompare the reasoning
Yes: it stays at the origin.Yes: it stays at the origin.
That solution requires zero initial velocity too.That solution requires zero initial velocity too.
No solution exists at the origin.No solution exists at the origin.
Both the stationary solution and moving oscillator solutions can pass through the origin.Both the stationary solution and moving oscillator solutions can pass through the origin.
No: its initial velocity is still free.No: its initial velocity is still free.
The coefficient of sin(2t) is not fixed by the initial position.The coefficient of sin(2t) is not fixed by the initial position.
A hintA hint
Try a sine wave with an arbitrary amplitude.Try a sine wave with an arbitrary amplitude.
NOW CHANGE THE EXAMPLENOW CHANGE THE EXAMPLE
Use seconds and metres. For , , , find .
A hintA hint
Here .
Work through the solutionWork through the solution
, so .
Check a proposed history by substitution and initial data; neither check replaces the other.Check a proposed history by substitution and initial data; neither check replaces the other.
0.5 The mechanics we will use#0.5 The mechanics we will use
A force is a push or pull, such as a floor pushing on your shoes. To calculate what it does, introduce momentum : mass times velocity. Bold symbols here are arrows with a magnitude and a direction. In Newton’s mechanics the total force changes momentum:
The force unit is the newton: . These equations describe ordinary speeds well; Chapter 3 develops their relativistic replacements.
Push a cart with a constant force of 6 newtons while it moves 2 metres in the direction of the push. The force transfers joules of energy to the cart. This transfer is called work. For a force along a straight track,
A force in the direction of motion does positive work; a force opposing the motion does negative work. One joule is one newton metre, so .
Where does this energy appear? For a cart of constant mass whose wheels have negligible mass, use and :
Thus the work changes the quantity , called kinetic energy. If our cart starts at rest and no other force does work, it gains 12 joules of kinetic energy. For a mass of 6 kilograms, gives .
A thrown ball gives us another way to store energy. As it rises, gravity does negative work and the ball loses kinetic energy. Near Earth’s surface, we assign it gravitational potential energy , where is its height above a chosen zero. A rise of increases by , exactly the kinetic energy lost to gravity. Ignoring air resistance, stays constant. On the way down, the exchange reverses.
A spring lets us watch this exchange repeatedly. Attach a cart to a spring on a level, frictionless track. Call its displacement from the unstretched position , positive to the right. A stretched spring pulls the cart left; a compressed spring pushes it right. Its stiffness is the restoring force per metre of displacement. The experiment starts with a 1 kg cart, a stiffness of 1 N/m, and a stretch of 1 metre.
Release the cart and follow the two energy amounts. At the middle, the spring is unstretched but the cart is moving. At either end of the motion, the cart is momentarily at rest but the spring stores energy. The cart’s momentum changes sign when it reverses; its kinetic energy remains nonnegative.Release the cart and follow the two energy amounts. At the middle, the spring is unstretched but the cart is moving. At either end of the motion, the cart is momentarily at rest but the spring stores energy. The cart’s momentum changes sign when it reverses; its kinetic energy remains nonnegative.
Watch the energy change places.
Release a stretched spring. Follow the cart through the middle, then watch it turn. The two energy amounts change; their sum stays fixed.
At a turning point the cart is momentarily at rest. The spring force is still acting, so the motion reverses.
Adjust the cart and spring
Changing a starting measurement returns the clock to zero. The track keeps its scale.
What is being calculated?
The default cart has mass 1 kg and spring stiffness 1 N/m. It starts 1 m to the right of the unstretched position, at rest. The track has no friction; the spring has negligible mass. Motion is shown at one simulated second per second.
Force and momentum carry a direction. Energy is a number. For this experiment, , while . The bar is divided in the ratio of these two energies. Its total is .
The motion obeys . Write ; its units are inverse seconds. With starting displacement and momentum , the solution is
Differentiating twice gives the required acceleration. At time zero it reproduces the starting position and momentum. One complete cycle takes . The model has no damping, impacts, external driving, or relativistic corrections.
For this ideal spring the force is , called Hooke’s law. To stretch it slowly, we apply the opposite force, . The work stored in the spring is
This also gives positive stored energy for compression, where : our applied force and displacement both point left. The default stretch stores . At the middle, all of that energy is kinetic, so gives a speed of . On successive passes the momentum is or , although the kinetic energy is the same. A real spring can dissipate energy into heating; this experiment omits that effect so the exchange is visible on its own.
More generally write , where is potential energy per unit mass. Outside a spherical body of mass ,
Here is distance from the center and is Newton’s gravitational constant. This choice makes approach zero far away. This is Newton’s model; the near-Earth experiments here lie in its useful range. Later chapters quantify its limits at high speeds and near very compact massive objects. The gradient is the arrow whose Cartesian components are the partial derivatives of . It points toward fastest increase. For this spherical example, differentiating with respect to gives . The minus sign in the acceleration law therefore gives inward acceleration of magnitude .
Pressure is force per area. A gas exerts pressure on a wall because collisions transfer momentum to it. The pressure unit is the pascal, . Pressure will matter when we ask how fluids move and how they affect gravity. The worked example below first shows how pressure can transfer energy.
Motion, stored energy, and pressure workMotion, stored energy, and pressure work
How can a force exchange energy without making energy disappear?How can a force exchange energy without making energy disappear?
See the idea
Force measures how momentum changes. Work measures how much energy that force transfers while its point of application moves. A book held motionless can experience a force without receiving mechanical work. These statements concern an ideal point particle or a specified mechanical system; your muscles can consume chemical energy while holding the book.Force measures how momentum changes. Work measures how much energy that force transfers while its point of application moves. A book held motionless can experience a force without receiving mechanical work. These statements concern an ideal point particle or a specified mechanical system; your muscles can consume chemical energy while holding the book.
Work it out
- Differentiate kinetic energy
For constant mass , momentum is and Newton’s law is . Dot with velocity and use the product rule. Integrating relates work to kinetic-energy change.
Why this step works Only the force component along the instantaneous displacement contributes to work.
- Introduce potential energy with its sign
For a time-independent potential , define . Along a trajectory the chain rule gives . Therefore is constant. Near Earth predicts downward force .
Why this step works A loss of potential energy balances a gain of kinetic energy under the stated conservative force.
- Use a piston to define pressure work
Pressure is normal force per unit area. A gas pushes a piston of area outward by . It does work on the surroundings. In an insulated expansion there is no heat transfer. Assume the piston moves slowly enough for the gas to pass through near-equilibrium states, with negligible friction; this is the quasistatic limit used here. Its internal energy , the energy stored in its microscopic motion and interactions, decreases by the work done. Heat supplied to the gas, called , adds energy to the gas.
Why this step works The sign follows which system does the work; pressure has the same dimensions as energy density.
Go deeper
Potential energy has an arbitrary zero. Replacing by for constant leaves unchanged and preserves every energy difference. It changes the energy reference while preserving the motion. Pressure work also provides a useful unit check: . Thus pressure times a volume change has energy units. “Insulated” means no heat transfer; it does not prevent work through a moving boundary. The symbol denotes energy transferred as heat during a process, while is the change in the system’s stored energy. Heat is a transfer, not an extra stored quantity to add to .
Test the idea Test the idea
FIRST, PREDICTFIRST, PREDICT
In an insulated quasistatic expansion against positive pressure, what happens to the gas’s internal energy?In an insulated quasistatic expansion against positive pressure, what happens to the gas’s internal energy?
Compare the reasoningCompare the reasoning
It is constant because insulation prevents all transfers.It is constant because insulation prevents all transfers.
Insulation blocks heat transfer; mechanical work can still cross the boundary.Insulation blocks heat transfer; mechanical work can still cross the boundary.
It decreases because the gas does work.It decreases because the gas does work.
With no heat supplied, dE = −p dV and dV is positive.With no heat supplied, dE = −p dV and dV is positive.
It increases because its volume increases.It increases because its volume increases.
Volume is not energy. The sign follows the direction of energy transfer.Volume is not energy. The sign follows the direction of energy transfer.
A hintA hint
Choose the gas as the system and track where the piston’s work comes from.Choose the gas as the system and track where the piston’s work comes from.
NOW CHANGE THE EXAMPLENOW CHANGE THE EXAMPLE
A particle falls from rest through in constant , without drag. Find its final speed.
A hintA hint
Set the lost equal to the gained .
Work through the solutionWork through the solution
. The mass cancels.
Conservation laws become useful when the system, force law, and direction of energy transfer are explicit.Conservation laws become useful when the system, force law, and direction of energy transfer are explicit.
0.6 Measuring with matrices#0.6 Measuring with matrices
A map uses one metre per horizontal square and two metres per vertical square. An instruction to move two squares right and one square up has map components , but its physical displacement is two metres right and two metres up. Pythagoras gives squared length square metres.
We can keep the map components and let a matrix carry the scale factors. With distances expressed in metres, defineWe can keep the map components and let a matrix carry the scale factors. With distances expressed in metres, define
The superscript means transpose: turn the column into a row for matrix multiplication. The vertical scale factor is squared because we are computing squared length. If the second instruction is , their physical dot product is
in square metres. The same rule accepts two arrows as inputs. Double either input while holding the other fixed, and the result doubles; adding two arrows in one input adds their results. These two properties are what linear in each input means. A rule with this property is called a bilinear form.in square metres. The same rule accepts two arrows as inputs. Double either input while holding the other fixed, and the result doubles; adding two arrows in one input adds their results. These two properties are what linear in each input means. A rule with this property is called a bilinear form .
Squared length uses the same arrow in both inputs. Doubling that arrow doubles both inputs, so its squared length becomes four times as large. This is why a bilinear rule can describe lengths even though length squared is not linear in the arrow.Squared length uses the same arrow in both inputs. Doubling that arrow doubles both inputs, so its squared length becomes four times as large. This is why a bilinear rule can describe lengths even though length squared is not linear in the arrow.
An inverse matrix undoes a linear map. It is not obtained by taking the reciprocal of every entry. For example,An inverse matrix undoes a linear map. It is not obtained by taking the reciprocal of every entry. For example,
Multiply them to check that the diagonal entries become one and the other entries zero. The result is the identity matrix, which leaves every input unchanged.Multiply them to check that the diagonal entries become one and the other entries zero. The result is the identity matrix, which leaves every input unchanged.
0.7 Flow through a box: flux and divergence#0.7 Flow through a box: flux and divergence
Imagine water flowing through an imaginary box. Let the arrow describe the mass crossing a unit area per unit time, in . This is a flux density. Only the part of the flow perpendicular to a face crosses that face. Multiply that component by the face area to obtain a mass flow rate.
For a numerical example, suppose 10 kilograms per second enter a one-cubic-metre box and 12 kilograms per second leave it. The box loses 2 kilograms each second. Its average mass density therefore decreases at .
To describe a small box at any position, let its side lengths be . Write for the flux-density component pointing along ; the superscript is a direction label, not a power. The left and right faces each have area , so their net outward flow is
The approximation is the local derivative rule from §0.1. Repeat it for the other two pairs of faces, add the results, and divide by the box’s volume. As the box shrinks, the result isThe approximation is the local derivative rule from §0.1. Repeat it for the other two pairs of faces, add the results, and divide by the box’s volume. As the box shrinks, the result is
This quantity is divergence, the net outflow per volume. Its units here are . If more mass leaves than enters, the density inside decreases. Local conservation of mass is therefore
Add this accounting over many little boxes. Flow across a shared face is outflow from one box and inflow to its neighbor, so it cancels. Only the outer boundary remains. That cancellation is the idea behind the divergence theorem: total divergence over a volume equals net flux through its boundary.Add this accounting over many little boxes. Flow across a shared face is outflow from one box and inflow to its neighbor, so it cancels. Only the outer boundary remains. That cancellation is the idea behind the divergence theorem : total divergence over a volume equals net flux through its boundary.
0.8 Estimating with a small parameter#0.8 Estimating with a small parameter
Suppose we need . It is close to . How much should we add? Let . Its value at zero is 1 and its derivative there is . The local prediction from §0.1 gives , so .
The symbol means approximately equal. Here is a dimensionless fractional change. The same method gives several useful estimates:
Each approximation discards terms beginning at order . For , those terms are on the scale of , though the coefficient depends on the function. “Small” requires a comparison: an extra centimetre compared with one metre is the ratio . An extra centimetre compared with a millimetre is not small.
Check dimensions before arithmetic. An acceleration must have length/time squared units on both sides of its equation. A distance and a time cannot be added directly. Different units of the same dimension, such as metres and centimetres, must first be expressed consistently. These checks often catch a mistake before a page of algebra does.Check dimensions before arithmetic. An acceleration must have length/time squared units on both sides of its equation. A distance and a time cannot be added directly. Different units of the same dimension, such as metres and centimetres, must first be expressed consistently. These checks often catch a mistake before a page of algebra does.
0.9 Check your understanding#0.9 Check your understanding
Try these before revealing the answers. They test operations taught above.Try these before revealing the answers. They test operations taught above.
1. If with , what are its velocity and acceleration?
and . At , these are and . The units of make both dimension checks work.
2. For , what is along , ? All inputs are dimensionless.
Substitution gives , so . The chain rule gives , the same result.
3. A tank receives water at for three seconds. How much volume is added?
. The time unit cancels the rate’s denominator.
4. Why does fail to specify one particular throw?
It specifies acceleration but leaves starting position and starting velocity free. Integrating twice exposes those two constants.It specifies acceleration but leaves starting position and starting velocity free. Integrating twice exposes those two constants.
5. Estimate to first order. What is the small parameter?
Write with . Then . Squaring this estimate gives , close to the original input. The first discarded term in the square-root expansion is .
Chapter 1 uses these ideas to ask a new question: what would a scale read if you and the scale were falling together?Chapter 1 uses these ideas to ask a new question: what would a scale read if you and the scale were falling together?
The idea to keepThe idea to keep
Position tells us where an object is. Velocity predicts its next small change in position; acceleration tells us how that velocity changes.Position tells us where an object is. Velocity predicts its next small change in position; acceleration tells us how that velocity changes.
Why does an equation for acceleration need two initial data?Why does an equation for acceleration need two initial data?
Integrating twice introduces two constants: the starting position and velocity. Different throws obey the same acceleration law.Integrating twice introduces two constants: the starting position and velocity. Different throws obey the same acceleration law.