Homology

Reference

Open Problems

Questions nobody can answer yet, from every corner of the book, and a few famous ones that were answered.

As long as a branch of science offers an abundance of problems, so long is it alive; a lack of problems foreshadows extinction or the cessation of independent development.

— David Hilbert, Paris, 1900, translated by Mary Winston Newson

Every exercise in this book has an answer that someone already knows. These questions do not. Each sits in the chapter that gives you the ideas to understand it, usually with something small you can try. Some are centuries old, some only a few decades. A few were settled in 2026, some of them by AI systems, and the claims are still being checked; each box says how far the checking has got.

Prelude

Part I · Foundations

  • Open problem Open since the 1970s

    Graph isomorphism in polynomial time

    Is there an algorithm that decides whether two networks of dots are the same network with the dots relabelled, in a number of steps bounded by a fixed power of

    Asked since the 1970s §1.2 Equivalence and Quotients

  • Open problem Open since 1902

    The Burnside problem for exponent 5

    Take two letters and form all words in them, and impose only the rule that for every word Is the resulting group, called finite?

    Posed by William Burnside, 1902 §1.3 Groups

  • Conjecture Open since 1933

    The Hadamard conjecture

    For every multiple of there is a square table of s and s of that size whose rows are pairwise orthogonal: any two different rows agree in exactly half of their places.

    Posed by Raymond Paley, 1933 §1.5 Linear Algebra

Part II · Shapes

  • Conjecture Open since 1965

    The Andrews–Curtis conjecture

    If a presentation with as many relations as generators describes the trivial group, it can be turned into by three kinds of moves: multiplying one relation by another, inverting a relation, and conjugating a relation.

    Posed by James Andrews and Morton Curtis, 1965 §2.3 Homotopy

  • Conjecture Open since the 1960s

    The smooth Poincaré conjecture in dimension 4

    Every 4-dimensional manifold that is homotopy equivalent to the 4-sphere is the 4-sphere not only up to homeomorphism but up to smooth deformation: has no exotic smooth structure.

    Asked since the 1960s §2.4 Manifolds and Surfaces

  • Conjecture Open since 1989

    Kalai’s 3ᵈ conjecture

    A convex polytope in dimensions that is symmetric about its centre has at least faces, counting the vertices, the edges, and so on up to the polytope itself.

    Posed by Gil Kalai, 1989 §2.6 The Euler Characteristic

Part III · Homology

Part IV · Cohomology

  • Problem Solution claimed in 2026

    Navier–Stokes existence and smoothness

    Do the Navier–Stokes equations of an incompressible fluid in three dimensions always have smooth solutions that last for all time, starting from any smooth initial velocity? Or can the velocity become infinite at some point after a finite time?

    Posed by Jean Leray, 1934; settled by OpenAI, with an unreleased AI model, 2026 §4.3 Differential Forms

  • Conjecture Open since 1982

    The 11/8 conjecture

    Every closed smooth spin 4-manifold satisfies where is the second Betti number and the signature of the intersection form. (For a simply connected manifold, spin means that is even for every

    Posed by Yukio Matsumoto, 1982 §4.6 Poincaré Duality

  • Problem Solution claimed in 2026

    A complex structure on the 6-sphere

    Can the 6-sphere be given complex coordinates: is a complex manifold of complex dimension

    Posed by Heinz Hopf, the 1940s; settled by Levent Alpöge, working with the AI model Claude, 2026 §4.8 Curvature and Characteristic Classes

  • Conjecture Open since the 1930s

    Hopf’s sign conjecture

    If a closed manifold of dimension has a metric whose curvature is negative in every direction (negative sectional curvature), then if the curvature is only nonpositive, then

    Posed by Heinz Hopf, the 1930s §4.8 Curvature and Characteristic Classes

Part V · The Bigger Picture

  • Conjecture Open since 1950

    The Hodge conjecture

    On a smooth complex projective variety, every rational cohomology class of type is a rational combination of the classes of algebraic subvarieties.

    Posed by W. V. D. Hodge, 1950 §5.3 Horizons

Settled

Conjectures that were proved, disproved, or shown to be beyond the reach of proof altogether: how each ended is part of the story. Claims still under review stay in the parts above.

  • Problem Neither provable nor disprovable

    The continuum hypothesis

    Is there an infinite set of real numbers that is larger than the set of natural numbers but smaller than Cantor guessed that there is not.

    Posed by Georg Cantor, 1878; settled by Kurt Gödel and Paul Cohen, 1963 §1.1 Sets and Functions

  • Problem Neither provable nor disprovable

    Whitehead’s problem

    Call an abelian group a Whitehead group if every short exact sequence splits. Every free abelian group is a Whitehead group. Is every Whitehead group free?

    Posed by J. H. C. Whitehead, about 1950; settled by Saharon Shelah, 1974 §1.4 Abelian Groups and Formal Sums

  • Conjecture Proved in 2023

    The shortest paper Möbius band

    A strip of paper of width and length can be bent into a Möbius band, without stretching, tearing or passing through itself, only if and the bound cannot be improved.

    Posed by Benjamin Halpern and Charles Weaver, 1977; settled by Richard Evan Schwartz, 2023 §2.2 Gluing Spaces Together

  • Conjecture Proved in 2003

    The Poincaré conjecture

    A closed 3-dimensional manifold in which every loop can be shrunk to a point is homeomorphic to the 3-sphere

    Posed by Henri Poincaré, 1904; settled by Grigori Perelman, 2003 §2.4 Manifolds and Surfaces

  • Conjecture Disproved in 2013

    The triangulation conjecture

    Every manifold can be cut into simplices: it is homeomorphic to a simplicial complex.

    Asked since the 1920s; settled by Ciprian Manolescu, 2013 §2.5 Simplicial Complexes

  • Conjecture Proved in 2026

    The cycle double cover conjecture

    In every network of dots and lines with no bridge (a line whose removal would cut the network in two), one can choose a list of cycles that uses every line exactly twice.

    Posed by George Szekeres and, independently, Paul Seymour, 1973–79; settled by GPT-5.6 Sol Ultra, an AI model of OpenAI, 2026 §3.1 Cycles and Boundaries

  • Conjecture Disproved in 2025

    Is unknotting number additive?

    The unknotting number is the smallest number of crossings that must be switched, in some diagram, to untie The conjecture: for all knots and

    Asked since 1937; settled by Mark Brittenham and Susan Hermiller, 2025 §3.7 Knots and Links

  • Problem Solved in 2024

    The Kervaire invariant one problem

    In which dimensions is there a closed framed manifold, a manifold with a consistent choice of directions at every point, whose Kervaire invariant is so that it cannot be simplified by surgery into a sphere?

    Posed by Michel Kervaire and William Browder, 1960–69; settled by Michael Hill, Michael Hopkins and Douglas Ravenel (2009), and Weinan Lin, Guozhen Wang and Zhouli Xu, 2024 §5.2 Homological Algebra

Statuses as of October 2026.