Friction, not viscosity

Honey and water

View

Camera

× 1.0

Layers

Readings

Two sealed, opaque bottles stand on a table at the same temperature. The left one holds honey, the right one water. In light they look alike: drag the divider to the right to see both.

Stirred, honey is ten thousand times more viscous than water. That is not what sets its gravitational glow. A liquid glows in proportion to its friction at the frequencies of heat, trillions of times a second, and honey is viscous because its molecules rearrange slowly: at those frequencies the rearrangement is frozen, and less than a hundred-millionth of a pascal second of its viscosity is left. What dissipates a shear there are the fast vibrations of hydrogen bonds and molecules, which honey and water share.

So in thermal gravitational radiation the two bottles glow within a small factor of each other: the honey here is 3.8 times as bright as the water, volume for volume, and 3.1 times along a line of sight through the middle of each bottle, glass included. That factor is all the camera has to tell them apart. Their temperatures are the same, and the glow says nothing of how a liquid pours.

The water carries the friction of its simulated spectrum, 8.6×10−5 Pas. Honey’s has not been worked out; it is given the most that a relaxing shear stiffness of 30 GPa, twice the water model’s, can send, 3.3×10−4 Pas: an upper bound, and real honey may be nearer the water, or fainter than it. Its everyday viscosity used as its friction would overstate its glow 30,000 times at least. Silica glass stands for the bottles, the floor and the walls; the glow of the room, about as bright as the bottles’, is taken away to begin with, and “Room” under Controls brings it back. The honey alone sends a detector of one square metre at the camera one graviton every 3.0×1010 years, the water one every 1.1×1011 years.

Expected brightness at the centre of view
0 gravitons s−1m−2sr−1Only the room lies along this line, and it is taken away; it gives 6.39×10−16 s−1m−2sr−1 here.

The gravity side is the expected thermal image: the glow of everything along each line of sight, with colour standing for temperature. It is what the camera would build up over a long exposure: everything in this view sends a detector of one square metre one graviton every 1.8×1010 years. Where the paper has an estimate of a material’s friction, the material carries it. The others keep the placeholder 10−3 Pas, unless the text above gives another.

“Tidal field” shows what every mass in the room has, hot or cold: the tensor at every point of a slice through the room, as a wash of colour for the direction of the stretch with fine strokes along it. Its value at the camera itself, in s⁻² and source by source, is under “Physics”.

Turning off “Room” removes the glow of the floor and walls, which is known in advance. Glows add up, so this is exact.

All demos